What usually happens next
It's usually repeated with albumin (a corrected calcium) and a PTH. In an otherwise well person, an overactive parathyroid gland is the most common reason.
Calcium and vitamin D supplements, thiazide diuretics and dehydration can push it up too.
What a high calcium usually means, and its common causes
When a calcium can read wrong
Most calcium in blood rides on albumin, so a low albumin makes total calcium read low and dehydration makes it read high. A long tourniquet can nudge it up. A corrected or ionised calcium settles it.
Read it with
Nearby results

Questions
Is a calcium of 11.8 mg/dL normal?
A total calcium of 11.8 mg/dL is above the usual 8.5 to 10.2 mg/dL. The usual range is about 8.5 to 10.2 mg/dL (labs vary by a few tenths).
What is 11.8 mg/dL in mmol/L?
2.94 mmol/L. Labs in different countries print Calcium in different units; the meaning is the same.
Worked out by LifeFrom from the BMJ's hypercalcaemia review and the usual lab range, and not yet reviewed by a clinician. For your own understanding: only a lab test, read by your clinician, diagnoses anything.